Twilight and the Jonas Brothers: Chastity Gone Wild

16 11 2009


I love how companies like Disney and Random House determine the relative “wholesomeness” of young adult novels, TV shows and pop stars by the extent to which they preach chastity and abstinence, when it is precisely that purity-preaching that fuels the fire of teenage hormones.  The enormously successful Twilight series, for example, is essentially a virginity parable, as Evgenia Peretz points out in the latest issue of Vanity Fair:

“In case you’ve been living in a remote forest, the series tells the story of Bella Swan, a shy newcomer to the town of Forks, Washington, who falls in love with Edward Cullen, a vampire since 1918, when he was bitten, who will be 17 years old for eternity. Though they are hopelessly in love, if they were to really fool around, Edward would lose control and bite her, turning Bella into a vampire as well—all of which puts the two in a permanent state of unquenchable lust, not to mention abstinence. This doubtless plays well with parents and bluenoses, like the author’s fellow Mormons. In fact, the whole setup could be seen as a metaphor for hanging on to your virginity.”

But somehow, instead of inspiring teens to hold onto their virginity, the book series and first Twilight movie have sent teens as well as their mothers into a raging sexual frenzy.  An article in Jezebel today entitled “…I Had More Sex When I Was Reading Twilight Than The Entire Few Months Before” addresses “the whole sexual element to Twilight” that is fueling “cougar” fantasies around the nation.  And let’s be honest– if a young adult novel can put the spark back into a 20-year marriage, it’s certainly not going to make teenagers zip their pants.  Robert Pattinson told Peretz in the Vanity Fair interview that he can’t leave his hotel room without being swarmed by horny teenagers trying to rip his clothes off as they cry and faint at his feet.


"Don't eat this juicy red apple, kids, and don't have sex, either."

The Jonas Brothers phenomenon is equally puzzling.  All three of them wear “purity rings” to announce to their fans that they will be virgins until they’re married.  These rings, along with the band’s “wholesome” lyrics, are supposed to set a good example for teens, and mothers pay thousands of dollars to get their young daughters into Jonas Brothers concerts as a healthy alternative to watching over-sexed pop stars like Britney Spears and Madonna.

In reality, Disney has taken three good-looking teen brothers, dressed them in tight rock-star jeans, put “Haha You Can’t Have Me” rings on their fingers and let them loose into a stadium full of screaming pre-pubescent girls.  The Jonases are then free to do borderline inappropriate things in the name of “good clean fun,” like spray massive amounts of white foam into the crowd with giant hoses (seriously).  Please see this clip of a hilarious Southpark episode parody on the subject:

or, see the entire episode if you have time, because it’s absolutely hysterical:

The irony of it all is that a Jonas Brother singing about the purity of his love and a book about two teenagers that desperately want but can’t have each other will get teenagers far more sexually excited than a slightly bloated Britney Spears with nipple tassels and a toddler on each hip, singing about her divorce and subsequent mental breakdowns.

Telling a teenager not to do something is the absolute worst way to make him or her not want to do it.  Perhaps a better strategy to virginify your teens is to tell them they better eat their vegetables, do all their homework and have sexual intercourse before 11 pm every weeknight or they’ll be grounded for a month.  That oughta buckle their chastity belts, no?




3 responses

16 11 2009

where can i find the cougars reading twilight?

16 11 2009

nice job, rambler. you made me actually give a crap about the twilight phenom AND the Jonas brothers in one post. but it only raises more questions
1) was there an 80s movie where a vampire cougar is chasing a virgin jim carey?
2) wasn’t no sex or i turn bad the same dilemma between Buffy and Angel?
2) how did a leather daddy get into the Jonas Bros concert in South Park?
3) the apple is knowledge of good and evil? or gettin’ it on? b/c marvin gaye doesn’t mention it.
4) I’m pretty sure twilight is only turning on girls and cougars. is this wrong?
5) let teenagers have sex about 5000 times, get careers, and a mortgage, and then they will do it less often. this is an answer, not a question.
i’m out.

17 11 2009

Can you even begin to imagine what would have happened if they had cast Kevin Jonas as Edward Cullen?

Honestly, I saw RPatz for the first time in HPIV (Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, not any sort of flu) as Cedric Diggory and I was disappointed because I thought Diggory should have been hotter. But after watching Twilight I can’t even look at his picture without getting at least a little hot and bothered. Is this because he makes out freely with Cho Chang in HP?

I guess what I mean to say is vampires turn me on more than wizards and I spend way too much time reading young adult fantasy novels.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: